What Goes Into a Structural Calculation Package (and How the EOR Reviews It)

What Goes Into a Structural Calculation Package (and How the EOR Reviews It)
In this article

A structural calculation package is the document that proves a structure can safely carry the loads it will see during its life. It records the design criteria and codes, the loads and load combinations, the analysis model and the check of every beam, column, slab, wall, connection and foundation. In the United States it is reviewed and sealed by the licensed Engineer of Record and often submitted to the building department with the permit set.

This guide explains what a complete package contains, how it is usually organized, who prepares it and what reviewers look for, so your team can produce or check one with fewer review comments.

Key takeaways

  • A good package lets a reviewer follow every number from load to member to foundation.
  • It starts with design criteria: governing code, risk category, loads and material properties.
  • Most U.S. packages reference IBC, ASCE 7, ACI 318 and AISC 360, plus local amendments.
  • The Engineer of Record seals the package; delegated components are sealed by the specialty engineer.
  • Missing assumptions and unclear load paths cause most plan review comments.

What a structural calculation package contains

SectionWhat it includes
Cover and indexProject, engineer, revision, table of contents
Design criteriaGoverning code and edition, risk category, materials, soil parameters, deflection and drift limits
LoadsDead, live, roof live, snow, wind and seismic parameters per ASCE 7
Load combinationsLRFD or ASD combinations used and their source
Analysis modelSoftware, model description, boundary conditions, key results and drift checks
Gravity system designSlabs, beams, girders and columns
Lateral system designShear walls, braced frames or moment frames, diaphragms and collectors
ConnectionsTypical and special connections, or the criteria for delegated connection design
FoundationsFootings, mats, piles or caissons based on the geotechnical report
AppendicesSoftware output, manufacturer data and reference calculations

Design criteria: the page reviewers read first

The criteria section sets the rules for everything that follows. It should state the code edition adopted by the jurisdiction (usually a version of the International Building Code from the ICC), the risk category, the occupancy and live loads, wind speed and exposure, seismic design category and site class, snow loads where they apply, material grades and the geotechnical values used for foundations. When a reviewer cannot find an assumption here, the comment letter usually starts with it.

How the package is organized

The clearest packages follow the load path: loads first, then the elements that carry them from roof to foundation. Each calculation should reference the drawing sheet and grid line it applies to, show inputs, formula or software result and the governing check, and end with a clear pass or fail ratio. Long software output belongs in an appendix, with a summary in the main body.

Who prepares and who seals it

The Engineer of Record is responsible for the structural design and seals the package. Much of the production, such as building the analysis model, running member checks and assembling the document, can be done by a support team working to the engineer’s criteria. That is how our structural calculation services and design support for engineering firms work: we prepare, the EOR reviews and seals.

Delegated design and deferred submittals

Some components are designed by the contractor’s or fabricator’s engineer under a delegated design clause: steel connections, metal stairs, precast elements or cold-formed framing are common examples. Those calculations are sealed by the specialty engineer licensed in the project’s state and submitted for the EOR’s review, often as deferred submittals. Precast and prefabricated systems are a frequent case, as explained in our article on calculations for precast and prefabricated systems.

Common review comments and how to avoid them

  • Missing or inconsistent loads between the calculations and the general notes on the drawings.
  • Unclear lateral load path: diaphragms, collectors and drag elements not checked.
  • Drift not verified against the code limit for the risk category.
  • Foundations not tied to the geotechnical report values.
  • Software output without explanation of the model or its assumptions.
  • Calculations that do not match the drawings after late design changes.

Keeping the model, the calculations and the drawings in one coordinated workflow is the best defense against the last point. It is the same principle behind bridging design and execution with detailed engineering. For the documents that surround the calculations, see the full set of structural deliverables.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a structural calculation package?

It is the document that shows, step by step, that every element of a structure resists its design loads, from the criteria and loads to members, connections and foundations.

Who can seal structural calculations in the United States?

A professional engineer licensed in the state where the project is built. For structures that require it, some states also require a licensed structural engineer (SE).

Which codes does a U.S. calculation package reference?

Usually the IBC as adopted by the jurisdiction, ASCE 7 for loads, ACI 318 for concrete and AISC 360 for steel, plus any local amendments.

Can a calculation package be prepared by an outside team?

Yes. A support team can prepare models and calculations to the engineer’s criteria, as long as the Engineer of Record reviews them, takes responsibility and seals the final package.

How long does it take to prepare a calculation package?

It depends on the size, structural system and how complete the architectural information is. A firm schedule should be set after reviewing the drawings.

Have a project?

Talk to a Grupo ADIPSA engineer

Tell us what you are building or what you need detailed, and we will reply with the scope and the next steps.

Keep reading

Related articles

Estimator preparing a rebar takeoff from structural drawings
Rebar Detailing

Rebar Takeoff Guide: How to Estimate Reinforcing Steel Quantities

How to do a rebar takeoff from structural drawings, with standard bar weights, a worked example and the items estimators most often
Slab rebar grid used as an example of a rebar takeoff
Rebar Detailing

9 Rebar Detailing Mistakes That Delay Pours (and How to Catch Them Early)

The rebar detailing mistakes we find most often in reviews, why they happen and a reusable checklist to catch them before the
Reinforcing bars overlapping at a rebar lap splice inside a wall form
Rebar Detailing

Rebar Lap Splices, Development Length and Hooks: A Practical Guide

How rebar lap splices, development length and standard hooks work, when to use couplers and how these criteria show up in rebar